Belief change and nonmonotonic reasoning are arguably different perspectives on the same phenomenon, namely, jettisoning of currently held beliefs in response to some incompatible evidence. Artificial intelligence 33 non monotonic reasoning in ai. But though commonsense reasoning has always appeared to be an attractive standard, the study of artificial reasoning need not and actually has not been committed to the latter. Mar 06, 2017 non monotonic reasoning in artificial intelligence a logic is non monotonic if some conclusion can be invalidated by adding more knowledge non monotonic reasoning is useful for representing. Nonmonotonic extensions of logic programming second. The definite clause logic is monotonic in the sense that anything that could be concluded before a clause is added can still be concluded after it is. Non monotonic reasoning is useful for representing defaults. The handbook of logic in artificial intelligence and logic programming is a multiauthor multivolume.
Twentieth century logicians have primarilystudied monotonic logic. In a nonmonotonic reasoning system new information can be added which will cause the deletion or alteration of existing knowledge. Roos, preferential model semantics, argumentation frameworks and closure properties, nmr 2012 2012 8 pages. First, it shows that ethical reasoning is essentially non monotonic and then that it has to consider the known consequences of actions, at least if we are interested in modeling the consequentialist ethics. Jul 03, 2010 non monotonic reasoning is based on default reasoning or most probabilistic choice. In previous topics, we have learned various ways of knowledge representation in artificial intelligence.
If there were no model in which the premises are true and the. Relatively few people have taken this form of inference, based on high probability, to serve as a foundation for nonmonotonic logic or for a logical or. These systems provide more expressive power than monotonic systems where adding facts can. In a sense, nonmonotonic reasoning is an outgrowth of mccarthys program. Download pdf readings in nonmonotonic reasoning free online. Nonmonotonic formalizations of reasoning deal with the problem of drawing conclusions when the description of either a situation or a problem is incomplete. Nerode classical logic is the study of safe formal reasoning. This workshop emphasizes the relationship between logic programming and nonmonotonic reasoning. In this article we will discuss about the reasoning system with uncertain knowledge. Relatively few people have taken this form of inference, based on high probability, to serve as a foundation for non monotonic logic or for a logical or defeasible inference.
Logic and artificial intelligence stanford encyclopedia of. Coskun sonmez reasoning iintroduction as studies of artificial intelligence continue, it should become apparent that progres in solving the problems of ai closely parelleled the development of tools and technics for manipulating knowladge. Makinson and gardenfors 1991 david makinson, pe ter gardenfors, relations between the logic of theory change and nonmonotonic logic, in. Since logic, as the laws of thought, is a product and practice of the human brain, it leads to another hypothesis that there is a bayesian algorithm and datastructure for logical reasoning. The logic of definite clauses with negation as failure is non monotonic. Need for defaults and non monotonic reasoning classical approaches for dealing with defaults closed world reasoning circumscription default logic auto epistemic logic modal logic modern approaches for dealing with defaults prioritized rules argumentation theories example uses of defaults. The reasoning is the mental process of deriving logical conclusion and making predictions from available knowledge, facts, and beliefs. However, particularly in the last 20 years, the mathematical study of reasoning nonmonotonically has developed in parallel to, and largely. Non monotonic reasoning attempts to formalize reasoning with ab kr incomplete information by classical logic systems. Nonmonotonic reasoning an overview sciencedirect topics. Belief change and nonmonotonic reasoning sans compactness. In this article we introduce a nonmonotonic reasoning engine, i. Executable temporal logic for nonmonotonic reasoning.
A logic is non monotonic if some conclusions can be invalidated by adding more knowledge. Nonmonotonic reasoning computer science university of. Recent success of bayesian methods in neuroscience and artificial intelligence gives rise to the hypothesis that the brain is a bayesian machine. Nonmonotonic logic and human reasoning in view of the fact that test subjects seem to perform very poorly in various paradigmatic reasoning tests e. The 18th international workshop on nonmonotonic reasoning nmr colocated with the international conference on principles of knowledge representation and reasoning. This book constitutes the thoroughly refereed postworkshop proceedings of the 6th international workshop on nonmonotonic extensions of logic programming, nmelp 96, held in bad honnef, germany, in september 1996. Download readings in nonmonotonic reasoning ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub. Inductive and deductive reasoning are the forms of propositional logic. For example, imagine you have invited someone to your house for. Department of computer science, university of toronto, toronto, ontario m5s 1a4, canada 1.
Wiktor marek author, miroslaw truszczynski author, r. Download pdf readings in nonmonotonic reasoning free. In common sense reasoning one often draws conclusions that have. The set of conclusions thus does not grow monotonically with the given information. The field of nonmonotonic reasoning is now an essential part of the logical approach to artificial. Investigations in this area typically assume, among other things, that the underlying background logic is compact, that is, whatever can be inferred from. Alexander bochman, in handbook of the history of logic, 2007. However, particularly in the last 20 years, the mathematical study of reasoning nonmonotonically has developed in parallel to, and largely separate from, research on monotonic logic. Nonmonotonic reasoning nmr is an essential part of the logical approach to artificial intelligence.
This is the first book that integrates nonmonotonic reasoning and belief change into a single framework from an artificial intelligence logic pointofview. Its birth is due to the research methodology suggested in mccarthy whose objective was a logical formalization of common sense reasoning for dealing with ai problems. Non monotonic reasoning nonmonotonic reasoning deals with the problem of deriving plausible conclusions, but not infallible, from a knowledge base a set of formulas. The second section distinguishes between the different aspects of ethical systems and attempts to focus on ethical reasoning. Jane nutter 16 thinks that sometimes probability has something to do with non monotonic reasoning. Introduction if artificial intelligence ai researchers can. The formalism of this paper is substantially superseded by that of applications of circumscription to formalizing common sense published in 1986. Stancs80788 circumscription a form of nonmonotonic reasoning john mccarthy abstract humans and intelligent computer programs must often jump to the conclusion that. Nonmonotonic logic stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
Roos, an argumentation system for reasoning with conflictminimal paraconsistent alc, non monotonic reasoning nmr 2014. The formalism of this paper is substantially superseded by that of applications of circumscription to formalizing. Circumscription circumscription a form of nonmonotonic reasoning was published in artificial intelligence in 1980dvi. In particular, it provides rigorous mechanisms for taking back conclusions that, in the presence of new information, turn out to be wrong and for deriving new, alternative conclusions instead. Analysis of algorithms for monotonic and nonmonotonic reasoning. Western philosophers developed classical logic over a period of thirtythree centuries after. If there were no model in which the premises are true and the conclusion false, the reasoning would be valid according to a standard, deductive, monotonic logic, and would not be an. Circumscription a form of nonmonotonic reasoning was published in artificial intelligence in 1980. In fact, the birth of nonmonotonic reasoning can be loosely traced to the birth of arti cial intelligence itself.
A default is a rule that can be used unless it overridden by an exception. Introduction if artificial intelligence ai researchers can agree on anything, it is that an intelligent artifact must be capable of reasoning about the world it inhabits. What is monotonic and nonmonotonic reasoning in artificial. Introduction to non monotonic reasoning master recherche sis, marseille. In 1980, the artificial intelligence journal published an issue vol. Non monotonic reasoning is based on default reasoning or most probabilistic choice. Monotonic reasoning can be defined in artificial intelligence.
The nine full papers presented in the volume in revised version were carefully. Nonmonotonic reasoning essays celebrating its 30th anniversary. Topics stable semantics autoepistemic logic abduction implementation. Contextdependent reasoning artificial intelligence 1993rd edition, kindle edition. Apr 27, 2017 36 videos play all artificial intelligence well academy conceptual dependency representation using examples in artificial intelligence duration. Laboratoire cnrs lsis 20102011a ai am indebted to laura giordano and alberto martelli for having provided me their course material. Prehistory of relations nonmonotonic reasoning is considered today an essential part of the logical approach to arti cial intelligence. The definite clause logic is monotonic in the sense that anything that could be concluded before a clause is added can still be concluded after it is added.
This is the second in a series of workshops that are bringing together researchers from the theoretical end of both the logic programming and artificial intelligence communities to discuss their mutual interests. Monotonic and nonmonotonic reasoning in artificial intelligence in. In this paper we view non monotonic reasoning as a special kind of process. Artificial intelligence foundations of computational. Its birth is due to the research methodology suggested in mccarthy whose objective. Hayes abstract humans and intelligent computer programs must often jump to the conclusion that the objects they can determine to have certain properties or relations are the only objects that do. Analysis of algorithms for monotonic and nonmonotonic. For example when we visit a friends home, we buy biscuits for the children. Monotonic and nonmonotonic reasoning in artificial.
The approach to both these subjects is based on a powerful notion of an epistemic state that subsumes both existing models for nonmonotonic inference and current models for belief change. Nonmonotonic reasoning provides formal methods that enable intelligent systems to operate adequately when faced with incomplete or changing information. Stancs80788 circumscription a form of nonmonotonic reasoning john. Adding knowledge in monotonic reasoning does not reduce the set of prepositions that arise. Contextdependent reasoning artificial intelligence 1993rd edition, kindle edition by v. Nonmonotonic reasoning and multiple belief revision. As temporal logic is a common formalism to specify and derive properties of processes, we introduce a variant of temporal logic as a general specification language for reasoning processes.
In common sense reasoning one often draws conclusions that have to be withdrawn when further information is obtained. The 18th international workshop on nonmonotonic reasoning nmr colocated with the international conference on principles of knowledge representation and reasoning kr nmr is the premier forum for results in the area of nonmonotonic reasoning. On the other hand, default logic exemplifies monotonic ity of the first kind and. Artificial intelligence foundations of computational agents. Nonmonotonic reasoning is a subfield of artificial intelligence trying to find more realistic formal models of reasoning than classical logic.
Some wellknown approaches to nonmonotonic reasoning are. Artificial intelligence 27 circumscriptiona form of non monotonic reasoning john mccarthy stanford university, stanford, ca, u. Western philosophers developed classical logic over a period of thirtythree centuries after its introduction in the form of syllogistic by aristotle 1 in the third century b. Nonmonotonic resolution of conflicts for ethical reasoning. In this article we introduce a non monotonic reasoning engine, i. Nonmonotonic reasoning nonmonotonic reasoning deals with the problem of deriving plausible conclusions, but not infallible. Logic programming and nonmonotonic reasoning the mit press. Belief change and non monotonic reasoning are arguably different perspectives on the same phenomenon, namely, jettisoning of currently held beliefs in response to some incompatible evidence. S is assumed to be true as long as there is no evidence to the contrary. Circumscriptiona form of nonmonotonic reasoning sciencedirect.
Stanford artificial intelligence laboratory memo aim334 februari 1980 computer science department report no. A non monotonic logic is a formal logic whose consequence relation is not monotonic. The present version has an addendum that was not in the published paper. In other words, non monotonic logics are devised to capture and represent defeasible inferences cf. Artificial intelligence 27 circumscriptiona form of nonmonotonic reasoning john mccarthy stanford university, stanford, ca, u. Anything can end before a clause is added, even after it is added. The objective of the article is to present solutions for problems occurring in classical expert systems based on. In a non monotonic reasoning system new information can be added which will cause the deletion or alteration of existing knowledge. Now we will learn the various ways to reason on this knowledge using different logical schemes.
503 1156 434 227 1247 751 1423 291 51 216 1218 1531 552 1466 976 327 913 898 458 1187 946 822 914 1029 646 226 374 582 1418 817 779 1370 1221 573 870 1001 1068 1162 213 1268 973 324